Why Getting Your Asking Price Right is Critical in Sarasota's Current Market

Bev Murray

If you’re thinking about selling your home in Sarasota, be aware that even though it’s still a seller’s market, choosing the right asking price is as important as it's ever been.

While home prices are generally rising, the pace has slowed due to higher mortgage rates impacting buyer demand. Additionally, the number of homes available for sale is increasing, giving buyers more options. This means your home needs to be priced competitively to stand out.

These factors make setting the right asking price essential in today’s market.

Many sellers are discovering this the hard way, leading to a higher number of price reductions. Mike Simonsen, Founder and President of ALTOS Research, points out:

    Looking at the price reductions data set... It all fits in the same pattern of increasing supply and homebuyer demand that is just exhausted by high mortgage rates... As home sellers are faced with less demand than they expected, more of them have to reduce their prices.

This often happens because sellers have not adjusted their expectations to the current market conditions. They might not be working with an agent who knows the local market or they might be relying on outdated information. This misstep can cost you time and money.

To avoid these pricing errors, it’s crucial to work with an agent who has in-depth knowledge of the Sarasota market.

A knowledgeable agent can help you avoid common pitfalls like:

Setting an Unrealistic Price


Some sellers base their asking price on personal expectations rather than market realities. An experienced agent uses factual market data to help you set a realistic price that attracts buyers.

Misjudging Comparable Sales


Without professional guidance, you might use the wrong comparable sales (comps) to price your home, leading to a misjudgment of its market value. An agent ensures you use accurate comps, providing valuable insights into competitive pricing.

Overvaluing Home Improvements


Sellers often overestimate the value of their home improvements. While certain upgrades can enhance appeal, not all will significantly boost your home's value. An agent can help you understand which improvements matter most to Sarasota buyers.

Ignoring Market Feedback


Some sellers resist adjusting their price based on feedback from potential buyers and market conditions. An agent can help you remain flexible and responsive to market feedback, ensuring your home attracts serious buyers.

Accurate pricing hinges on understanding current market conditions, and a skilled agent has the expertise and data to set the right price for your home. The right agent will develop a strategic pricing plan based on these conditions, positioning your home to sell quickly and effectively.

Bottom Line


In today’s market, setting the right asking price is more critical than ever. To avoid costly mistakes and ensure your home is priced correctly, let’s work together. With the right strategy and expert guidance, we can make sure your home stands out in the Sarasota market.

Featured Listing In Siesta Bayside

4526 Woodside Rd Sarasota

$2.8M 4526 Woodside Rd Sarasota FL 34242

  • 4 beds
  • 3 baths
  • 2422 sqft
  • 0.26 acres
  • 1969 year built

Come see this beautiful light-filled canal front home in a quiet neighborhood of Siesta Key. This well-designed flexible floorplan comprising of four bedrooms plus a den is currently used as a 3 bed, 2 office space. The second bedroom has its own entrance so you can easily create an in-law suite if needed. The light and bright primary suite is split from the other rooms. The lot is deep and lushly landscaped and the screened pool cage is nicely proportioned. The heated saltwater pool is huge – approx. 40 x 16 – and there is plenty of covered and open deck space for lounging and dining. This is an excellent option for boaters - 95 feet of seawall with a 10,000lb boat lift and mooring for up to a 45 ft. cabin cruiser right in your backyard! It is a short 3-minute cruise to Sarasota Bay and 10 minutes to the Gulf of Mexico. If you are not a boater but love to sit and watch the world go by, you will appreciate the fact that there are no neighbors directly across the canal so you can enjoy a wide-open view of the waterway. The house has been recently updated with beautiful luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout and stylish quartz countertops and backsplash to refresh the open-concept kitchen with island and breakfast bar. Tucked away on a quiet, dead-end street yet just a short bike ride from the beach and the lively activities of Siesta Key Village, this prime location offers convenient access to both the north and south bridges. Whether you're a full-time resident, seeking a second home, or looking for a seasonal investment property, this well-maintained, beautiful waterfront home will surely meet your needs!